Latest Update on fog cloud 5e

Fog Cloud 5e:

A bank of fog billows from the stage you designate.
The spell doesn’t function underwater.

Highlights of fog cloud 5e

If you cast this spell, a light fog climbs from the floor to fill a 20-foot-radius world to some extent you will see within reach. Each round a dwelling animal begins its turn within this insanity, it will need to roll up a Constitution rescue throw or endure 5d6 necrotic harm.

If you were standing through a fog cloud rather than doing anything, you are hidden (hidden and unheard, each of the cube I submitted previously ), no stealth test required. No-one conceals you. Move a few spaces inside the cloud on the following turn and quaff a healing potion?

Take a bow or toss a dagger?

Are you holding a flashlight within the sidewalk? I will indicate that sufficient light illuminates the mists to provide enemies a fair thought for the heart of mass, which means you are not concealed (even though an ingenious player could create a lightweight origin inside the fog faraway from himself on draw flame!). Take a bow or toss a dagger? The minimum sound there and everybody it does is indicate a line or after the narrow trail.

The fog changes color to become red, the more harm it inflicts. As an actor, you will move the mist overcloud in to 60 ft, but the spell ends when it moves out of scope. Any around any of your preferred allies begin their turn inside the cloud. However, every profit of three temporaries hit points until the cloud inflicted harm on enemies through a prior round.

Someone can keep a fog cloud in a little flask known as a vapor jar.

The cloud could dissipate as a conventional fog throughout a strong enough breeze and won’t cast underwater.

Since the spell generated air along with the fog, it may be wont to rekindle the air distribution of a spell jammer that’d spent too long in uncontrolled space. Regardless of the temporary obscuring impact, the brand new air created remained after the spell’s duration.

Unlike nonmagical shadow, additional profoundly obscured areas made by spells like fog cloud do normally. It prevents monsters from having the ability to see through them (unless there’s a feature, spell, magical item, etc. That permits them to do differently – like the warlock’s Devil’s Sight eldritch invocation when it concerns the shadow charm ).

Nonmagical darkness

The difference is that nonmagical darkness does not demand things blocking your vision, only the lack of lighting in that region. By comparison, if there is a lot of fog (whether mundane or magical) between A and B, then it might be tougher (or perhaps impossible) that you view B from A.

(Notice that this depends upon a common-sense interpretation of nonmagical shadow – that the rules do not draw such a distinction, presumably since they expect individuals to employ logic and common sense in knowing how routine darkness functions.)

Therefore, a monster in the center of the fog blur would not observe a beast away from the cloud, as the monster outside would not be able to watch the creature within the cloud. If one attacked another, the hiding attacker gets canceled out with their drawback from seeing their goal.

Rules inquiries concerning Fog Cloud 5e

I was attempting to determine the principles around advantages/drawbacks around attacking to / inside / outside of a Fog Cloud 5e. Here are the relevant passages in the PHB which are confusing me

You produce a 20-foot-radius world of fog based on a reach point.

It is about A heavily obscured place –like darkness, opaque fog, or compact foliage–cubes vision entirely.

A blinded creature can not see, and mechanically fails any skill assessment which needs sight. Attack rolls against the monster possess an edge, and the monster’s attack rolls have drawbacks.

Text about assaulting a monster that can not see you or who you can not view (p193-4, PHB):

When you strike a goal that you can not see, you’ve got a drawback on the attack roll.

When a monster can not see you, you’ve got benefits on attack rolls.

If conditions cause a roster to possess both benefit and disadvantage, it deems you to have neither of these, and you roll up one d20. I can be true even if multiple conditions impose drawbacks, and just one grants an edge or vice versa. In this kind of circumstance, you’ve neither advantage nor disadvantage.

So, Here Is What I am requesting in fog cloud 5e

If two beasts from the cloud have drawbacks to attack as they’re blinded, they benefit to shoot since their goal can not view them. The outcome is that they roll without advantage or disadvantage to assault?

Is this true about a monster utilizing a ranged attack to the cloud from beyond the shadow (they profit adv. because the goal is blind, but drawback since they can not find the destination)?

Does this mean if you’re standing 599 ft. away from a goal, you truly enhance your chances to strike with a longbow if they become greatly obscured by the fog cloud? (your drawback for shooting outside normal range completed by the advantage or disadvantage piled on for eyesight problems)

Does that imply profoundly obscuring an imperceptible unit using a fog cloud efficiently”de-cloaks” them since the drawback from attacking invisible goals gets phased out from the benefit you gain from being hidden, providing you a straight d20 roster?

A situation arose in my group session of HotDQ a week and that I was interested if I could find some guidance/wisdom in the resident rule lawyers and other nice denizens of ENWorld.

Battle in fog cloud 5e

It is a battle situation. The celebration comes up from a magician who casts Fog Cloud 5e. There are protector drakes within the AOE. The magician is out of the AOE.

Q&A fog cloud 5e d&d

The protector drakes inside the cloud are all concealed in the party’s perspective, as is everything else at the cloud due to heavy obscurement. (Red token to the remaining AOE).

Quite simply, do you rule that the fog blur’s AOE blocks line of sight, which makes the participant view :

Do you rule which the fog blur AOE blocks line of sight inside the cloud, which makes the participant view :

It appears that it might block the line of sight entirely, granting complete cover to the magician. However, the biggest question I have is: how can you manage, in either situation, a character seeking to go into the square of an enemy he can not see?

By way of instance, suppose Vannqkorr that the hasted, blessed, ferocious GWM barbarian does not need to lose his anger rather than attacking this around, so that he charges the fog blur and attempts to enter the distance of one of those protector drakes, what occurs? Therefore I house-ruled it. Burnt 10 feet of movement and he could not put in the space (5 feet to try to maneuver in, 5 feet to conduct back/recover equilibrium ). He had him, and the protector drake does a very low DC acrobatics test to prevent falling likely from bumping into each other.

Are there any rules for it?

In that case, what are you? Otherwise, how can you/do you manage this situation? It is logical that, after trying to proceed, the personality becomes conscious of a monster from the adjacent square and can opt to attack with drawbacks. However, how can you manage unwittingly trying to move to a square occupied by an enemy?

Additionally, my view of Fog Cloud went a great deal after this specific experience. The party did not have some wind-based spells ready to cancel it. Appears to unlock a great value of strategic choices to get an outgunned low-level magician if he’s got a couple of meatshields/pets to stand at the cloud.

Fog cloud certainly blocks the line of sight to all those outside the fog blur in addition to inside. It is exactly like every mundane visual barrier. So two individuals standing on opposite surfaces of the fog cloud wouldn’t be able to observe each other.

Hidden Characters in Fog cloud 5e

As for conducting into hidden characters in battle. Is the protector drake hiding from the fog cloud? To put it differently, has it gathered a thriving stealth test and intentionally avoided actions that could show its position? (Rapid movement, attacking, drawing weapons, speaking, etc.) In the event the protector drake isn’t super well concealed, I’d rule the barbarian finds it before actually trying to go into the animal’s square.

(I’d likely give advantage to some passive understanding score against a monster who’s standing directly alongside you, but the drawback to the barbarian who’s charging, so they’d cancel out.) If that’s the instance, there would not be a penalty. There is something in the fog with you!” Then permit the barbarian to select what to do.

The barbarian

The drake will surely hear that the barbarian if he’s charging. And when he’s actively concealing, he’ll have the ability to make the most of it. As a response, the drake could attempt to go to the barbarian. Or permit the barbarian to maneuver through his square foot but take an attack of opportunity. When the drake has solved its response, the barbarian can last its turn typically and assault the drake. (Depending on what happens, he may want to stand out from being prone initially, but when he is hasted and contains yet another 30 ft to burn off, that is probably fine) The drake felt likely.

The barbarian produces a strength rescue or knocks prone. (Edge, in this situation, visiting the monster with momentum.) I take it to include breaking point of sight. The Fog Cloud is much opaque. That isn’t the same as” concealed.” Until the drakes actively attempt to conceal, the PCs should know just what square they are present.

Attacks from the drakes have drawbacks since no one can view them. But besides, they have an edge since the drakes are blinded. Therefore this cancels. Subsequently, the drakes have a drawback in their attacks (they’re overwhelmed) but benefit contrary to the PCs that can not see them, so again, this cancels.

Until the drakes are knowingly concealing, there is no issue with crashes – everyone knows where everyone else is. I don’t think trying to move to a hidden monster’s area is covered in the rules.

I believe in getting a fog cloud, I would only have the inspector stop brief. Anyone would possibly spend an additional 5′ for the tried movement, and the hidden monster comes out.

The blur vision in Fog cloud 5e

As the fog blur obstructing vision, it would not have happened to me to ask this question. It will. The thought that you could not see what is within the cloud; however, you need some X-ray vision that allows you to protect your eyesight beyond the shadow, is foolish. Whether the rules mention it is insignificant. I don’t typically regard” common sense” as a persuasive argument in D&D .however, in such an instance… yeah, this is merely common sense.

Now, the question of what occurs when you unwittingly attempt to input an enemy square is much more intriguing. I’d tend to state the barbarian should make a DC 10 Dex rescue or fall prone. If the barbarian gets the reprieve, he has a choice: He could either drop back to his preceding square. It means wasting the 5 feet of motion he utilized attempting to go into the enemy square). Or he could try to push the enemy and keep moving (breaking him an assault, each of the” pushing a monster” principles ). In any event, he knows about the occupied square.

Some things I still feel aren’t pushed enough in TTRPG:

1) The GM is also a player, and they aren’t the sole person responsible for the game being fun,
and
2) as a GM, if you aren’t having fun? A good group will want to help fix that and ensure everyone is enjoying themselves.

— King Amy ???? wicked artwitch (@sephiramy) October 7, 2020