Is primal Savagery 5e good compared to Shillelagh in dnd?
Primal Savagery 5e appears weak compared to Shillelagh to some of us. Both the spells assist you to do melee damage, but 5e primal Savagery administers a flat 1d10 acid ( average: 5,5 ), and Shillelagh 5e 1d8 + along with your spellcasting ability (4,5 + ~3 on average)
primal savagery 5e Spell details
- Source: Xanathar’s Guide to Everything
- Transmutation cantrip
- Casting Time: 1 action
- Range: Self
- Components: S
- Duration: Instantaneous
You can channel primal magic into creating your teeth or fingernails to sharpen, set to deliver a corrosive attack. You may make a melee spell attack upon one creature within 5 feet of you. On a sudden hit, the target will take 1d10 acid damage. After you complete the attack, your teeth or fingernails recover naturally.
At Higher Levels. The spell’s damage rises by 1d10 when you reach Level 5 (2d10), Level 11 (3d10), and Level 17 (4d10).
Spell Lists. Druid
- Cantrip transmutation
- Casting Time: 1 bonus action
- Range: Touch
- Components: V S M (Mistletoe, a shamrock leaf, and a club or quarterstaff)
- Duration: 1 minute
- Classes: Druid
You are holding the wood of a club or quarterstaff. It is imbued with nature’s power. You may use your spellcasting ability in place of Strength for the attack or damage rolls of melee attacks applying that weapon for the duration. The weapon’s damage dies a d8. The weapon also enhances magic, if it is not already. The spell terminates if you cast it afresh or if you let go of the weapon.
Primal Savagery 5e vs. Shillelagh in dnd
Creatures seldom have immunity or resistance to magic bludgeoning damage. It is while immunity and resistance are more familiar to acid damage. A one-time bonus action loss that 5e Shillelagh requires ( Compared to Primal Savagery 5e) does not seem sufficient of a reason to have it do 2+ more damage (on average). The spell’s damage rises by 1d10 when you reach the 5th level (2d10), 11th level (3d10), and 17th level (4d10).
Unless you are using Shillelagh with 3+ attacks in your dnd game, you agree to eventually average more loss at higher levels with the Primal Savagery than with a unique melee attack. You ought to weigh in pros and cons over many encounters and the advantage of cantrips over pure routine variations. Shillelagh, by default, does not progress with levels, while in d&d, Primal Savagery does. That makes it more useful as a melee action and excellent support for the war caster’s opportunity attack. Additionally, on top of the scaling of Primal Savagery 5e, you might note that you don’t perpetually have a stick or any quarterstaff handy.