Let us know how Shield Master 5e feat works with shove, knock prone & Dex save in dnd

Shield Master 5e feat lets you knock enemies prone. Applying the Attack action, you might make a special melee attack to shove a creature in dnd. It is to knock it prone or push it off from you.

Shield Master 5e in dnd is among the most impressive feats you could achieve as a Sword and Board Fighter. The +2 bonus on Dex saves isn’t the most interesting aspect that comes with Shield Master. The ability to move (knocking enemies that are vulnerable or moving their position) in addition to the possibility to avoid taking the loss after a successful Dex save is much more exciting. The utility of the Shove ability will be determined by your DM’s understanding of its operation and the composition of your group.

The original Sage Advice ruled that you could use the bonus Shove before applying your attacks to the main action. That lets you knock your enemy down and then attack them from a position of advantage. Then they changed their minds later on, stating that you cannot just take the Attack move first but also utilize all of the attacks before using Bonus Action.

The way that it is ruled impacts the efficiency of the technique

Knocking objects down can be very beneficial if you’ve got many enemies in melee (everyone has an advantage!). However, if your allies are predominantly firing at range, They’ll hate it (everyone suffers a disadvantage! ).

It lets you knock enemies down to take advantage of bonus action. (or off cliffs if would like)

It also increases your Shield AC as an unrestricted increase to Dexterity saves. It also stacks the ability to improve! With a Shield +3, you’ll get an increase of 5 on the value of your Dex Save more than proficiency Dex saves up to level 17.
It gives you an EVASION as a response.

Do you have the ability to shove into the ground using the shield master?

The only method to get your opponent into a position of vulnerability appears to be to utilize an action surge following your shield master skill. You must attack before you can use the action boost. Once you’ve completed one attack, you’re able to apply the bonus action to all other attacks.

Can shield master be used against 5e fireball in dnd?

Although you’re not able to use it against spells such as fireball or lightning bolt, there’s plenty of spells that can affect the Dex saves. The ability to at least add 2 points to these saves is a great thing, particularly because the classes that will most likely benefit from this ability aren’t proficient at Dex saves!

Does the Shield Master shove the same as the normal shoving, other than the action timings within D&D 5E?

Indeed, it doesn’t have another description, so the conclusion is that bonus actions grant the specific strike that is “shove”:

If you use the Attack action during your turn, you may use an extra action to push a creature to within five feet using your shield.

Shove 5e dnd

Using the Attack ability, you can create a specific melee attack to push the creature away or cause it to fall, or force it to move out of your way. If you can make multiple attacks using this Attack move, the one is a replacement for one.

The target must be no more than one size bigger than you, and it must be within reach. Instead of rolling an attack making a roll, you can make a strength (Athletics) check that is contested through the targets Dexterity (Athletics) or Dexterity (Acrobatics) check (the person who is the target decides which ability to utilize). The check is successful if the target is in a state of incapacitation. If you win, you either knock the target to the ground or move it five feet away from you.

The ruling has been formally announced in the revised 2019. Sage Advice Compendium:

Shield Master feat lets you shove someone. Shield Master feat lets you throw someone around as an extra action when you choose to take your attack. Do you have to take that bonus action before taking your Attack action?

No. The bonus action that comes with Shield Master feat has a prerequisite: performing the Attack action when you turn. While you’re in each turn you have, you have the choice of when you do the bonus action after you’ve completed an Attack action. Simply deciding to take action doesn’t suffice, and you have to complete it before taking this bonus step.

This kind of setup is common in the game’s rules. In other words, the “if” must be satisfied before the “then” comes into play.

Does Shield Master 5e grant DEX save bonuses vs. single-target spells?

The second benefit of Shield Master feat (PHB, page. 170) declares:

If you’re not incapacitated, you can add the shield’s AC bonus to any Dexterity saving attempt you make against a spell or any other negative effect that is only targeted at you. So there is no gain to the saving bonus associated with AoE spells. But the 3rd benefit can indeed work for AoE spells, granting you the ability to escape AoE spells for all points in the same region/direction for the rest of the turn.

Suppose you’re subject to the effect that permits you to make a Dexterity saving throw to deal only half the damage. In that case, you could use your reaction to avoid taking a loss if you are successful on the saving throw. That will put your shield between you and the cause of the impact. Because half of the reactions last for the rest of the turn, such as Shield or Feather Fall, and if additional AoEs originate from the same spot in space, Your shield effect should continue to provide this Evasion effect. That means there could be six spells that can be considered for the second section of the feat. However, many more are eligible for the third portion of the feat as it covers all spells that require Dexterity saving to be made. Don’t mix the two components of this feat!

How do you get a shield and a means to attack from a distance with D&D 5E?

Various one-handed weapon types can be used at range, such as hands-on crossbows, darts the sling, and any other weapon that can be thrown.

Alternately, you can make use of spells. A cleric may use shields and also have a holy signet on the shield to focus their spellcasting. First-level spells and cantrips can be useful for making ranged attacks or even damaging creatures that don’t make a saving throw. These spells comprise Sacred Flame, Toll The Dead as well as Guiding Bolt. There are even more on higher levels.

Other classes that are proficient in shields and a wide variety of ranged combat spells are Artificer, Druid, Oath Of Valour Bard Eldritch Knight, and Hexblade warlock.

It is possible to use a hand crossbow, a sling, or any other 5e weapons with the throwing property. You could technically throw any one-handed weapon and make use of the rules of the weapon that are improvised. I’m currently playing the role of a Sea Elf Eldritch Knight that often throws her trident around and then utilizes the bonus action offered by weapon bind to bring it back to her. Suppose an artist places the returning Weapon Infusion onto a spear, javelin, or cloud of dagger 5e. In that case, it can also be a possible design.

Shield Master – Can the shield push be used before any attack?

The shove can’t be taken before the assault.

The first part from this feat of Shield Master feat is:

If you use the Attack action during the turn you take, they can take advantage of a bonus move to attempt to push an animal to within five feet of your shield.

Jeremy Crawford has changed the rules regarding this recent. At the beginning of 2015, he wrote on Twitter with the following message. Like most bonus action, it is possible to choose the time and choose when the Shield Master shove can come either before or after the Attack move. However, he has changed this in a comment that was posted earlier this week. A clarification on bonuses: If an option states that you can perform something as a bonus if you take Y, you must complete Y before doing X. If you’re a Shield Master, the bonus action needs to occur immediately after that Attack action. The player decides when the bonus action will occur after that turn.

The problems and Solutions explained.

The Problems

The Narrative Problem. The issue is that the forced order is absurd. It almost makes more sense to charge into and be the leader with the shield and shove. This limitation is an aspect of game design.

The Mechanical Problem. If the order of the shove is reversed, the shove mechanic could result in an illegal move. If, for instance, you force a character to the edge of reach (say, for example, of a mountain), the character will stop taking your Attack action.

That is the place where tables are just playing. You don’t lose your actions. You can make use of it to attack another thing. However, if there are no other creatures within range, then you cannot use the attack you pledged the Shield Master. It could be a violation of the act.

The Solutions

There are some ways to manage this issue:

Solution 1

Your action is canceled due in the event of an illegal act. Alternately, you can still use the Attack action. However, you’re not able to take any actions because you have no legal targets. It is possible to move, but your turn is done. That is a tough but simple decision.

Applying solution one is straightforward. Include a clause that says your actions expire when there aren’t any legal targets following the completion of an action bonus.

Before or following the Attack action during your turn, you may use an extra action to push an animal within 5 feet of you using your shield. If there aren’t any targets that are legal to attack, the action is over.

Solution 2

Your action can be useful to perform other actions. It is logical since you’ll still have that “time” on your turn to perform an action. What’s stopping characters from doing the Dodge move after successfully eliminating threats immediately?

The issue of Solution 2 is that it lets you break the economics of an action. It is possible to use a bonus action to take the character out of their range and then pick an alternative attack. That is a very niche technique. The inclusion of a condition to the effect that “you must move close to the nearest target if possible” renders the technique complicated and a bit clunky. It can also be circumvented by a skilled player who will make use of their energy before taking the initiative.

What’s the biggest thing that could occur if we ignore this rule and let it open to other possibilities?

So what happens if someone decides to use the Dodge move after throwing an opponent off the high cliff? It’s a smart defensive move. It’s possible to fall prone when you’re not moving left.

What happens if an individual uses a Ready move to get ready for a fight with any creature close to them? It’s a good tactical move. It’s not like it takes up any more time on your time.

What happens when a person pushes a target into formation to prepare for their Cast a Spell move? It is awesome! Do you mean that the battlemage drove the goblins into the pantry before firing Burning Hands?

Is one of those excessively powerful? It’s an extremely effective method of melee to knock the creature into danger and unleash all your attacks to gain an advantage. It’s impressive! Compare it with what we would expect players to perform regularly.

If we’re worried that knockdown, then advantage attacks is too potent the tactic, this one must have a different limit rather than limiting the economy of action. Perhaps something similar to the Charge mechanic used by uses by the Centaurs:

The principles of strong mechanics should be equally applicable regardless of the order in which you choose the mechanics. The Charge mechanic is effective since movement can be applied at any time during your turn. It is not a limitation to using it either before or after the action. The same way by opening up the economy of action preserves authenticity.

Before or following the Attack action during your turn, you may use an extra action to push a creature within five feet of your shield. If there are no legal targets that you can take on, you can select a different option.

Solution 3

If you do not have legal targets following the 5e Shield Master shove attack, you take it as an ordinary attack. It permits you to continue to move, make use of any attacks that remain, and preserve the bonus action for future purposes.

Although it’s not the most elegant option, Solution 3 would be difficult to write concisely since it has some bizarre aspects using exchange action economies that are not typical of 5e’s game design. It is possible to implement an alternate solution that allows you to utilize bonuses to initiate an attack if you are successful by using the shield shove. It causes another problem that means you can’t finish your attack by using the shield master. That is fixable, but you’ll need to explain the specifics of every scenario, which can be extremely difficult. If you’d like to do this, include this bullet point in the current rule:

If you select the Attack action when you turn, you can attack to push a creature within 5 feet of you using your shield. If you succeed, you can use an additional action to create an attack with a weapon against any creature within your distance.

Best Solution

Trying to figure out how these mechanics function leads to the conclusion that this issue should be solved through subtraction and not adding. In the end, what’s why you should tie this bonus shield action to an Attack action? Set the shield free.

Sure, having an advantage on an array of attacks sounds great; however, you should compare it to other loadouts of weapons Dual-weapon fighters can utilize their bonus actions to create an attack that is normal and does damage, so it shouldn’t make a difference the fact that dual wielder’s considered to be one of the weaker abilities. Top weapon fighters can get bonuses on a critical hit or kill in addition to the huge ten damage bonus mechanic that comes from The Great Weapon Master. Polearm fighters receive the bonus attack of a d4 along with all the modifiers they have. Archers can disregard distance and cover. They also receive +10 damage from Sharpshooter that can be enhanced with Elven Accuracy.

Summary of Shield Master 5e

Source: Player’s Handbook

The use of shields is not only to defend yourself but also as a means of offensive purposes. There are many advantages when using shields:

If you use the Attack action during your turn, you may use an additional action to knock a creature to at least 5 meters from you using your shield.

If you’re not incapacitated, you can apply the AC bonus of your shield to any Dexterity save you make in the face of an attack or effects that only target you.

Suppose you’re affected by an effect that permits you to make a Dexterity saving throw to deal only half damage. In that case, you could use your reaction to avoid taking a loss if you are successful on the saving throw, thereby putting your shield between you and the cause of the result.