Is Shadow of War, Shadow of Mordor, Super Saiyan 4, Shiki, Or Star Wars Resistance Canon?
The Middle-earth video game series considers Shadow of War and Shadow of Mordor canon, but not the larger Lord of the Rings canon. Neither the Dragon Ball anime nor manga series consider Super Saiyan 4 canon. Shiki is a Japanese video game and media franchise character from the Touhou Project, and there is no established canon for her. The Star Wars franchise considers Star Wars Resistance to be canon.
Is Shadow of War Canon?
Shadow of War is canon to the Legends continuity of The Lord of the Rings. It was released before Disney bought Lucasfilm, and, as such, it is not considered to be part of the current Star Wars canon.
Shadow of War and The Lord of the Rings
Shadow of War is considered canon within the Legends continuity of The Lord of the Rings. It draws heavily on the existing lore developed by J.R.R. Tolkien and expands on it in a manner that is consistent with the principles of world-building that define Middle-earth. It examines characters and events that are part of the main narratives of The Lord of the Rings and offers an entirely new perspective on the battle against Sauron.
Set in the time between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, Shadow of War offers additional background and context to the events leading to the War of the Ring. It introduces characters and locations while including familiar faces from the works of Tolkien. While some elements of the game might be original, they are trying to keep the same legends that make Shadow of War a valuable addition to the Legend’s continuity.
Canonicity and the Tolkien Estate
When examining canonicity, it is essential to think about the authority that defines the canon. The Tolkien Estate oversees the legacy and works of J.R.R. Tolkien. However, it has not issued an official statement about the canonicity of Shadow of War. However, it is worth noting that the Tolkien Estate has maintained a strict canon for a long time and has only recognized those works composed by Tolkien himself as the definitive works.
Ultimately, the canon of Shadow of War is often a source of contention among players. While the game is based on the principles of world-building from Middle-earth and incorporates the existing lore, its status as a canon ultimately depends on each player’s interpretation. For many gamers and players, the pleasure and enjoyment of Shadow of War lie in its ability to provide an immersive experience in the vast tapestry of Middle-earth, regardless of its official status as canon.
The Influence of Disney’s Acquisition
The impact of Disney’s Acquisition is to make clear that the reference to Disney’s purchase of Lucasfilm in the prompt does not refer to the canonicity of Shadow of War in The Lord of the Rings. Disney’s acquisition is specifically related to the Star Wars franchise and the subsequent creation of the current Star Wars canon. Shadow of War’s status as either canon or non-canon is not a result of the event.
Is Shadow of Mordor Canon?
Shadow of Mordor is set in the Lord of the Rings universe. However, it has a story that isn’t directly related to the movies or books. The game was created by Monolith Productions and published by Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment.
Shadow of Mordor presents its own story, self-contained within the Lord of the Rings universe. Although it is set in Middle-earth and includes familiar characters and locales, The events described in the game aren’t directly linked to the events in Tolkien’s novels or the Peter Jackson film adaptations. Therefore, Shadow of Mordor can be considered an alternative version or a storyline that focuses on different adventures in the same fantasy universe.
The game introduces its protagonist, Talion, an armed ranger on a mission to get revenge against the forces of Sauron. It features unique gameplay mechanics like the Nemesis System, which dynamically creates enemy characters and their interactions, providing depth and replayability. Although Shadow of Mordor embraces the aesthetic and lore of Middle-earth, Its uniqueness distinguishes it from the standard canon of Tolkien’s work.
Canonicity and Tolkien’s Intent
The issue of canonicity is often centered around the creator’s intentions, J.R.R. Tolkien. While the works of Tolkien are the principal source material for the Lord of the Rings universe, The author was aware of the idea of multiple interpretations and versions of his mythology. Tolkien acknowledged the possibility of various iterations of his stories and even rewritten elements in his works.
Because of Tolkien’s receptivity to various interpretations, it could be said that The Shadow of Mordor can coexist as a valid form of expression within the larger context of Middle-earth. The game honors the world of Tolkien while focusing on its unique gameplay mechanics and storylines. While it may not go exactly with the original vision of Tolkien, it is a fun and immersive experience for those who are fans of the Lord of the Rings universe.
The Role of Expanded Universe
When discussing canonicity, it is crucial to think about the concept of an expanded universe of materials. The expression “expanded universe” refers to additional works by artists, authors, and game developers who explore and expand on the current mythology. These works are often found alongside the original canon and are a part of the overall fabric of the fictional world.
Shadow of Mordor can be considered an entry point into the new universe of The Lord of the Rings. It brings its unique characters, stories, and game elements to the overall mythology, giving fans an alternative view of Middle-earth. Although the game’s events may not be considered canonical in the strictest sense, they can be appreciated and enjoyed as part of the larger saga of Lord of the Rings lore.
Is Super Saiyan 4 Canon?
Super Saiyan 4 is not canon for the Dragon Ball franchise. It first appeared within the Dragon Ball GT anime series but is not considered canon by the person who created Dragon Ball, Akira Toriyama.
Super Saiyan 4 debuted in Dragon Ball GT, a series that continues the story of Dragon Ball but was not directly written by Akira Toriyama. Dragon Ball GT is an update to Dragon Ball Z but is not considered canon for the manga’s original or following Dragon Ball Super anime series. While Toriyama did create character designs for GT, he wasn’t directly involved in the story process.
In the end, Super Saiyan 4 exists solely in the non-canonical realm of Dragon Ball GT. The transformation is accomplished by an original method that involves the Golden Great Ape form and Saiyan control. Although Super Saiyan 4 may be loved by fans and praised for its distinctive appearance, it’s not considered part of the official canon of Dragon Ball as defined by Toriyama.
Akira Toriyama, the creator of Dragon Ball, has emphasized the importance of his manga and subsequent Dragon Ball Super anime series as the main canon of the franchise. The involvement of Toriyama in the creation of Dragon Ball Super ensures that it aligns with his vision of creativity. Toriyama has transformed the characters, like Super Saiyan God and Super Saiyan Blue, which are canonical.
While Toriyama contributed some ideas and character designs to Dragon Ball GT, he did not manage the whole series, which led to its omission from the canon. Thus, Super Saiyan 4 falls out of the Toriyama vision to create the Dragon Ball universe and is not considered canon in the franchise.
Legacy and Fan Appreciation
Despite its non-canonical status, Super Saiyan 4 has left an impression on Dragon Ball fans and the larger anime community. The unique design of the transformation, as well as the strength it embodies, have been well received by a wide range of viewers. Super Saiyan 4 continues to be praised and admired for its unique appearance and the excitement it brought to the Dragon Ball GT series.
Although it isn’t officially canon, Super Saiyan 4’s acclaim has resulted in its inclusion in numerous Dragon Ball video games, merchandise, and fan-created items. Fans often explore alternative possibilities and stories within the Dragon Ball universe, embracing Super Saiyan 4 as part of their enjoyment of the series.
Is Shiki Canon?
Shiki is one of the characters in the Fate/Grand Order mobile game. She is not a canon character for the Fate franchise. However, she is considered one of the most popular characters among fans.
Shiki’s Origins in Fate/Grand Order
Shiki debuted in Fate/Grand Order as a collaboration character from a different Type-Moon film, Kara no Kyoukai: The Garden of Sinners. This partnership allowed Shiki to enter the Fate/Grand Order and become an able servant. Fate/Grand Order operates on an alternate timeline and introduces characters and other events that differ from the primary Fate series.
Shiki’s appearance in Fate/Grand Order has allowed players to witness her interactions with other famous Fate characters. However, it is important to remember that her participation in the game doesn’t make her a part of the main Fate storyline. Shiki’s appearances and interactions in Fate/Grand Order must be viewed as distinct from the main storyline of the Fate franchise.
The Canonicity Question
The determination of the significance of Shiki in the Fate franchise can be difficult. The Fate universe comprises numerous timelines, alternate realities, and spin-off material contributing to its vast storyline. While certain characters and storylines are considered canon in certain Fate stories, some are in other universes or as part of spin-offs that are not canon.
Shiki’s canonicity has been influenced by her background in Kara no Kyoukai and her subsequent appearance in Fate/Grand Order. Although Kara no Kyoukai is a Type-Moon story, it is distinct from the primary Fate canon. In this way, Shiki’s inclusion in Fate/Grand Order could be viewed as a collaboration or crossover rather than an extension of the primary Fate storyline.
Despite Shiki’s non-canonical status, she has cultivated a huge following among Fate/Grand Order fans. Her unique character design, skills, and enthralling tale have made her a popular character in the game. Shiki’s popularity has resulted in numerous merchandise items based on her character, including fan art and cosplays.
The Fate franchise, which includes Fate/Grand Order, encourages fans to explore and appreciate the vast universe in various ways. While Shiki might not be canon to the main Fate storyline, her inclusion in the Fate/Grand Order has let fans experience her unique character alongside other adored Fate characters. This is why Shiki remains adored by her fans.
Is Star Wars Resistance Canon?
Star Wars Resistance is canon for the Star Wars franchise. It was released following Disney’s purchase of Lucasfilm, and as such, it is considered part of the present Star Wars canon.
Star Wars Resistance is canon for the Star Wars franchise. It was released after Disney bought Lucasfilm, and, therefore, it is considered part of the present Star Wars canon.
Disney’s Acquisition and the Current Canon
Star Wars Resistance premiered in 2018, following Disney’s acquisition of Lucasfilm in 2012. After the purchase, Disney established a new approach to the Star Wars canon, streamlining and integrating the story across different media. This included films, TV series, comics, books, and video games. The idea was to build a unified and interconnected universe in the universe of Star Wars.
This is why Star Wars Resistance was created and released within this brand-new canon framework. The show explores the events and characters directly tied to the bigger sequel trilogy and extends the fight against the First Order. The show is considered a part of the official Star Wars canon and contributes to the overall narrative tapestry of the franchise.
Continuity and Consistency
One of the most important factors determining canonicity is consistency and conformity to the established lore of the same franchise. Star Wars Resistance aligns closely with the canon established by the films, acting as a bridge between The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi. The show also features appearances by characters familiar from the films, including Poe Dameron and Captain Phasma. It introduces new characters that play important roles in the fight for the Resistance’s victory.
The story and events depicted in Star Wars Resistance respect the established lore and follow the continuity established in the sequel trilogy. The series examines the rise of the First Order, the Resistance’s efforts to combat it, as well as the personal lives of the characters. By maintaining the same consistency and expanding on the current canon, Star Wars Resistance solidifies its place in the official Star Wars universe.
Integrated Storytelling Approach
Disney’s take on the Star Wars canon encompasses a coherent storytelling strategy in which diverse media platforms are part of the narrative. Star Wars Resistance is vital to expanding the narrative beyond the films, providing more depth and meaning to the sequel era. The character arcs and events explored in the series complement and enrich the overall Star Wars experience.
Additionally, Star Wars Resistance’s integration into the canon is evident from its relationship to other canonized mediums like comics and novels. The characters and storylines of the show are referenced and expanded in these additional works, which further bolster its status as a canonical part of the Star Wars franchise.
What is “Shadow of War,” and is it part of the official Middle-earth canon?
“Shadow of War” is a video game and a sequel to “Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor.” As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, while the games are based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth setting, they are not considered part of the official Middle-earth canon established by the author’s works.
Is “Shadow of Mordor” considered part of the official Middle-earth canon?
“Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor” is a video game set in J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth universe. Like “Shadow of War,” it is not part of the official Middle-earth canon and should be considered as separate from Tolkien’s original works.
What is “Super Saiyan 4,” and is it part of the official Dragon Ball series canon?
“Super Saiyan 4” is a transformation seen in the anime series “Dragon Ball GT.” As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, “Dragon Ball GT” is not part of the official Dragon Ball series canon, as it was not directly based on the original manga created by Akira Toriyama.
Is “Shiki” part of the official anime and manga canon?
“Shiki” is a horror anime and manga series. While it has a dedicated fan following and is an official work, it does not directly relate to a broader canon, as it is a self-contained story.
What is “Star Wars Resistance,” and is it part of the official Star Wars canon?
“Star Wars Resistance” is an animated series set in the Star Wars universe. As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, “Star Wars Resistance” is considered part of the official Star Wars canon, as it is produced by Lucasfilm and features new stories within the established galaxy.
Are these works enjoyable even if they are not part of the official canon?
Absolutely! While these works might not be part of the official canon in their respective universes, they can still be enjoyable and entertaining for fans of their respective genres. Many non-canon stories offer unique perspectives and original content that can be appreciated on their own merits.