Is Dead Man’s Questions, Dio Over Heaven, Discovery, Dissadia, Or Doom3 Canon?

In determining the canonicity of different works from “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure,” there are some key things to take into consideration. “Dead Man’s Questions” is widely regarded as canon because of its official publication as well as its direct ties to the “Diamond is Unbreakable” arc.

However, the canonical status of “Dio Over Heaven” is controversial among fans as it’s a spin-off novel that was not written by Hirohiko Araki. “Discovery,” a standalone short story, is deemed not canon because it doesn’t relate directly to any of the story plots. It’s important to know that “Dissidia” and “Doom 3” aren’t related to the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” canon because they’re separate video games that feature various characters.

Is Dead Man’s Questions Canon?

The JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure series canonically references Dead Man’s Questions. Hirohiko Araki, the series’ original author, did both the writing and the illustrations for it. From June 16 to July 21, 1999, it appeared in the Manga Allman magazine from Shueisha. Later, it was included with Araki’s other tales in the collection Under Execution, Under Jailbreak.

Official Publication and Connection to the Main Story

“Dead Man’s Questions” is a one-shot manga written and illustrated by Hirohiko Araki, author of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” The first time it was published, it was within Weekly Shonen Jump in 1999 as a special story that was set within the “Diamond is Unbreakable” arc, which is the fourth installment in the story. It follows the story of Yoshikage Kira, who is the principal villain from the “Diamond is Unbreakable” arc, following his death.

The fact that “Dead Man’s Questions” was officially published in a respected manga magazine is a testament to its position as one of the main stories. Furthermore, the events in the manga are directly connected to the “Diamond is Unbreakable” arc, which provides additional information about Yoshikage Kira’s character and reveals his life following his death. The connection with the story implies that it is possible that “Dead Man’s Questions” can be considered canon.

Author’s Involvement and Inclusion in Adaptations

Another thing to think about is the role played by Hirohiko Araki, creator of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure,” in the development of “Dead Man’s Questions.” Araki designed and wrote the manga in one shot, and it is clear that the manga was written with his unique idea and intention. As the main source for the series, Araki’s contributions add weight to the arguments for the canonicity of the manga.

In addition, “Dead Man’s Questions” was included in a few versions of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” For instance, it was included within the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure: All-Star Battle” video game and was also mentioned in the adaptation to anime of the “Diamond is Unbreakable” arc. Its inclusion has been recognized and included in official adaptations, indicating it is part of the accepted continuity. “Dead Man’s Questions” is part of the established continuity.

Debate and Personal Interpretation

In spite of the above factors, it is crucial to recognize that the issue of the extent to which “Dead Man’s Questions” is considered canon in the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” series isn’t a simple one. Some fans question the canonical status of the manga because it is only a single-shot manga instead of an integral part of the series. They feel that its distinct character is distinct from the canonical narrative.

Is Dio Over Heaven Canon?

JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure series does not consider Dio Over Heaven to be canon. Although it was written by Hirohiko Araki, the light novel is not regarded as being part of the main continuity. The novel is set in an alternate reality where Dio triumphs in the end and contains a number of different characters and events from the main series.

Written by a Different Author

A crucial point to take into consideration is the fact that “Dio Over Heaven” is an easy-to-read novel that was written by Nisio Isin and illustrated by Hirohiko Araki, the artist of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” While Araki illustrated the story, the narrative itself was written by a different writer. This raises doubts about the authenticity of the story in the sense that Araki is the main authority for the series.

Sequel to “Stone Ocean”

“Dio Over Heaven” serves as a sequel to the sixth manga, “Stone Ocean,” and is focused specifically on Dio Brando. The story explores the talents of Dio and his pursuit of ultimate power. While it develops Dio’s character and provides more growth, it is important to remember that it is set following the events of the main series.

Debated Canonicity

The canonical nature of “Dio Over Heaven” is an issue of debate among the fans. Some say that since it was not directly written by Araki and includes aspects that are not in the primary storyline, it is, therefore, an unrelated spin-off instead of an official work. Others argue that since it is a continuation of the tale of Dio Brando in addition to being licensed by the official as such, it could be considered canon in its own right.

Differentiating Spin-offs and Canon

To assess the canonical quality of “Dio Over Heaven,” it is important to distinguish between spin-offs and the primary series known as “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” Spin-offs typically explore stories that are not part of the main story or provide alternate interpretations of the characters or incidents. While they can add dimension, they aren’t necessarily considered part of the main story. In this instance, “Dio Over Heaven” could be considered an offshoot that provides a distinct view of Dio’s character.

Is Discovery Canon?

The owner of the Star Trek franchise, CBS Studios, regards Discovery as canon. As a result, the show’s events are regarded as being included in the official Star Trek timeline. Due to some of the show’s deviations from the accepted Star Trek canon, some fans do not believe that Discovery is canon.

Standalone Story

“Discovery” is a short story written by Hirohiko Araki. It was included as part of the compilation “Under Execution, Under Jailbreak.” It is a standalone story independent of the main story arcs in “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” The characters and events in “Discovery” do not directly link to the larger storyline of the series.

Lack of Main Story Integration

As opposed to other spin-offs or additional content that could provide additional insights or look into various aspects of the show, “Discovery” remains a distinct story. The show introduces characters and situations that differ from the canon that is already established. This means that it doesn’t directly contribute to the overall plot or extend the existing legends in “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.”

Non-Canonical Status

Due to its nature as a standalone and the lack of connection to the main storyline, “Discovery” is generally considered to be non-canon by its fans. It is an individual work that provides a different story in the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” universe. While it can be appreciated because of its unique storytelling and artistic quality, it is not able to carry the same authority as the main manga and anime series.

Personal Interpretation and Appreciation

The non-canonical nature of “Discovery” does not diminish its importance as a unique work. People can still enjoy the creativity Araki adds to the story, even if it’s not part of the established canon. Like any other additional or standalone work, its value and appeal lie in the perception and appreciation of the person reading it.

Is Dissadia Canon?

Although it is loose canon, the Dissidia series is regarded as canon for the Final Fantasy series. As a result, not all of the games’ events correspond to those in the main Final Fantasy games. The existence of the Warriors of Cosmos and Chaos, as well as some of the character backstories, are considered canonical elements of the Dissidia series.

Crossover Nature

“Dissidia” is primarily a crossover game that combines characters from several Final Fantasy games into a single world. Jotaro Kujo’s appearance on “Dissidia” represents a crossover of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” and Final Fantasy rather than a direct addition to “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” canon within the game’s plot. The primary focus in “Dissidia” is on the combat and interactions between characters from various Final Fantasy titles.

Separate Universe and Narrative

The “Dissidia” series is a distinct and unique game The Dissidia series features a distinct universe and storyline from the other Final Fantasy games involved. Although it incorporates aspects and characters from Final Fantasy titles, it creates its own storyline and mythology within the framework of its game-based series. Thus, any reference to Jotaro Kujo’s character in the series “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” in “Dissidia” should be understood as a different depiction or interpretation within the “Dissidia” universe rather than an extension canonical to “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.”

Non-Canonical Status

Due to the character of “Dissidia” as a crossover game and its distinct story and universe, the game is often viewed as non-canon in comparison to the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” series. While it is an enjoyable possibility for character crossovers as well as gaming experiences, however, the characters and events in “Dissidia” do not have any direct influence on or impact on the canon that is “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.”

Appreciating the Crossover Experience

Despite not being a canonical title, “Dissidia” provides fans of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” with an opportunity to watch Jotaro Kujo fight with players from The Final Fantasy universe. The game lets players play with imaginative matchups and develop their own scenarios for crossovers. The players can enjoy the crossover experience and relish the game and interaction provided in “Dissidia” while recognizing that it is distinct from the classic “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” storyline.

Is Doom3 Canon?

There is some disagreement among fans regarding Doom 3’s canonical status. While some fans think Doom 3 is a prequel to the original Doom games, others think it is part of a different continuity. Since ID Software has not issued an official statement on the subject, it is ultimately up to the individual fan to decide what they think.

Different Universes and Genres

“Doom 3” belongs to the genre of first-person shooters that are set within a science-fiction horror world. The other, “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure,” is an anime and manga series that centers around supernatural powers and epic battles. The two works are in distinct universes and genres, without any known connection or crossover between them. So, “Doom 3” and “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” should be considered distinct entities, each having its own canonical status.

Unrelated Narratives and Characters

The plot and characters in “Doom 3” have no relationship or connection with the story in “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” follows the Joestar family through the generations, whereas “Doom 3” focuses on an individual marine fighting off an army of evil creatures on Mars. The absence of shared characters and narrative elements adds to the distinctness of the characters in the two films.

Non-Canonical Status

Due to the absence of any connection or crossover established, “Doom 3” is generally thought to be non-canon when compared with “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure.” The fact that it is an online game set in a totally different world and with no narrative elements puts it outside the canon of “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” series. The fans of the two series “Doom 3” and “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” will take note of the distinctive characteristics of each piece while also recognizing their distinct canonicity.

Enjoyment in Separate Contexts

Even though “Doom 3” and “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” are distinct entities, players can enjoy both games in their own contexts. “Doom 3” offers a thrilling gaming experience with high-energy action and terrifying elements, and “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” captivates viewers with its distinctive story, intricate characters, and supernatural battles. Recognizing the non-canonical character that is “Doom 3” within “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” allows players to enjoy and appreciate each game on their own terms.

FAQ’s

Is “Dead Man’s Questions” considered canon in the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” series?

“Dead Man’s Questions” is a spin-off manga featuring a side story in the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” universe. While it is written by the original author, Hirohiko Araki, it is not considered part of the main canon and exists as a separate entity.

Is “Dio Over Heaven” considered canon in the “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure” series?

“Dio Over Heaven” is a light novel spin-off that presents an alternate scenario involving the character Dio Brando. Similar to “Dead Man’s Questions,” it is not considered part of the main canon and is separate from the main storyline.

Is “Discovery” considered canon in the “Star Trek” franchise?

“Discovery” is a television series within the “Star Trek” franchise and is recognized as part of the official canon. It contributes to the ongoing storyline and continuity of the “Star Trek” universe.

Is “Dissidia” considered canon in the “Final Fantasy” series?

“Dissidia” is a crossover fighting game featuring characters from various “Final Fantasy” games. While it includes an original storyline, it is generally not considered part of the main canon of the individual “Final Fantasy” games.

Is “Doom 3” considered canon in the “Doom” video game series?

“Doom 3” is generally considered part of the “Doom” series canon, as it is an official entry in the franchise and contributes to its overall storyline. However, it may exist within its own self-contained continuity separate from other games in the series.

Is “Doom 3” referenced or connected to the events of other “Doom” games?

“Doom 3” is a standalone entry in the “Doom” series, and while it shares some thematic and gameplay elements, it is not directly connected to the storylines of other “Doom” games. Each game within the series tends to have its own self-contained narrative.